Life, Love and Talmud in Medieval France


Reading Group Guide - Prequel: SECRET SCHOLAR
Discussion Questions


1. Joheved and Salomon begin the novel as strangers.
* How does the bond between them develop and change with time?
* What do they have in common?

2. Since Talmudic times, women have been excluded from Talmud study.
* Why does Joheved want to study Talmud?
* Did the novel's Talmudic quotes aid your understanding of the Jewish religion and its laws?
* Did any of these surprise you? Intrigue you?
* Why don't more Jews study Talmud today?

3. Joheved's world is filled with demons.
* Were you surprised that an educated man such as Salomon believed in them?
* What about the other superstitions her family accepted?
* Do you recognize any that are practiced today?

4. Rashi's Daughter: Secret Scholar is filled with carefully researched historical anecdotes that the author uses as inspiration for her imagined scenes.
* Did you wonder what was fact and what was fiction?
* How could you find out?

5. Rivka is upset with her daughters learning Talmud.
* Are her objections reasonable?
* Why would men not want women in a position of knowledge?
* Do women today still try to hide their intelligence? Why?

6. Joheved and Meir have an arranged marriage, as do Salomon and Rivka.
* How does Joheved and Meir's relationship compare to Salomon and Rivka's?
* To Miriam and Benjamin's?
* Could you imagine an arranged marriage vs. marrying for love?

7. Relations between French Jews and Christians were fairly tolerant during the 11th Century.
* Was this lack of overt anti-Semitism surprising?
* What other myths about medieval times did this book debunk?

8. Religion was a powerful force for both Jews and Christians in medieval times.
* Is religion as powerful now?
* How does your religion, or lack of one, influence your life?

9. The author includes a glossary of terms at the end of her novel.
* Was it necessary for your understanding and enjoyment?
* Why do you think she weaves the Hebrew and French words into her characters' dialogue?

 


Mag Maggie Margaret Anton Parkhurst Rashi's Daughters Joheved Miriam Historical Fiction Romance Novel Book Jewish Talmud Rashi